Computing Dissertation guidelines – MSc Dissertation Report
Toggle
Computing Dissertation guidelines – MSc Dissertation Report – Sheffield Hallam University
- Introduction
1.1 Aim of the Dissertation
In formal terms, the aim of the module is to undertake a substantial independent piece of work relating to your chosen course and to produce a dissertation based on this work.
- You will be able to draw on knowledge, skills and experience gained during the course and elsewhere. You will be able to apply methods and skills developed in other modules.
The dissertation will evaluate and reflect on both the research and the approach taken, and place it in an academic context.
- The research can be undertaken in a variety of contexts. It may be directly linked to experience within the work environment or may involve more theoretical issues to be evaluated in a purely academic framework.
The Dissertation is the last stage in the process leading to the award of a master’s degree.
1.2 Learning Outcomes
On successful completion of this module, you will be able to:
- Understand established approaches, methods and techniques, and critically select those relevant and appropriate to undertake an independent project in order to address a research problem in your course of study.
- Apply the selected approach and evaluate the deliverable and outcomes of the project in your course of study.
- Draw valid conclusions from the evidence gathered and produce an academic dissertation at the master’s level that formulates an argument.
1.3 The Dissertation process
The assignment involves independent and autonomous research, supported by a named supervisor. Guidance from your supervisor will allow you to plan and execute your research project and produce a Dissertation based on this work. Additional support will be available through Blackboard, including discussion forums and online resources. You are strongly encouraged to also use resources from the University library, either physically or by online access.
You are required to meet your supervisor over a total of 8 half-hour sessions. The first 4 sessions will be conducted in a group format, focusing on common dissertation themes like literature reviews, research ethics, and methodology. The remaining four sessions will provide individualised guidance on your specific dissertation project. Ensure that at least one of your meetings each month is planned to take place with your supervisor on campus. For international students, the attendance for the supervisory meetings will be recorded on JISC by your supervisor for UKVI monitoring.
The supervisor will read at least one draft of the dissertation before submission. The time for reading and feedback will be agreed between student and supervisor in accordance with the assessment submission dates.
- The Dissertation
2.1 Introduction
A master’s Dissertation is the written presentation of your research work and places your research in an academic context within your chosen domain. It discusses the objectives and focus of the research project you undertook. It describes and justifies the methodological choices that were made and shows how these were implemented. The Dissertation discusses and evaluates the outcomes and deliverable of your research project and critically assesses the approach considering your experience of undertaking the research work. In addition, the dissertation integrates a critical review of the literature and draw conclusions from the work you have done. Finally, it discusses any further research that could build on the work performed.
2.2 The content and structure of the dissertation
An MSc Dissertation is typically between 12,000 and 15,000 words in length. This may however depend upon your subject area and chosen research approach. A dissertation that is largely based upon interview data and observation records can be of greater length than a dissertation that is based upon software development and statistical data, for example, as it will usually make intensive use of interview quotations or observation records. A useful guideline is that the dissertation should enable you to formulate and justify a clear argument concerning your research question. Quantity does not equal quality.
It is not possible to be prescriptive about the specific chapters to be included in an MSc dissertation, since each research project is different. Indeed, there is wide variation in the nature of the research undertaken by MSc students from very technical programming to those involving management issues in a complex organisational context.
You should always bear in mind that while your work may be clear in your head, a reader may have no prior knowledge of your work at all. You should always start where the reader is, rather than where you are, and anticipate potential questions from a reader.
2.3 Layout and Format
2.3.1 Layout
The basic pattern of an MSc Dissertation is as follows:
Cover page. This should include a statement stating whether the dissertation is confidential or not. Appendix A contains an example Cover page.
Acknowledgements to individuals or organisations that have assisted you in the project. This should be on a separate page.
An abstract not exceeding 300 words produced in single spacing on one side of A4 paper providing a synopsis of the dissertation stating the nature and scope of the work undertaken and of the contribution made to knowledge. The synopsis should communicate the essence of the dissertation to answer the question “in a nutshell, what is the whole thing about?” It should be possible to read the abstract on its own.
Contents page showing chapters and page numbers.
Main Body of the dissertation.
References and bibliography.
Appendices:
Appendix A – Research project plan.
Appendix B – Ethics Form and Publication Procedure form.
Appendix C – Information Sheet and Consent form.
Appendix D – Data gathering instruments, other relevant documents.
Appendix E – Primary Data, software code, etc.
Appendix n – Graphs, tables, other support materials
2.3.2 Format
The format of the dissertation should follow the specifications below:
• The dissertation should be printed on A4 paper (210 mm x 297 mm) of good quality and sufficient opacity.
- Only one side of the paper should be used.
- Margins must be:
§ Left (binding edge) 40 mm
§ Other margins 20 mm
• One and a half spacing should be used. The font size should be 12 point.
Pages must be numbered consecutively through the main text. Page numbers should be located centrally at the bottom of the page and 20 mm above the edge of the page. Pages before the first page of Chapter 1 should be numbered using Roman numerals.
References to published work should use the APA system. The University library has a comprehensive set of resources on citing and referencing; refer to this content if you need help: https://libguides.shu.ac.uk/referencing
Every graph, diagram, snippet of code, table, etc. included in your Dissertation report must be numbered and have a title that clearly describes it – without having to read through the whole document to understand it.
- Ethics and Integrity
3.1 Research ethics
Sheffield Hallam University is committed to the promotion of excellent research practice and to maintaining the highest standards of rigour and integrity in all aspects of our research. Its research ethics policies and procedures are regularly reviewed and updated to ensure good practice, and that all research undertaken at the University is subject to appropriate ethical scrutiny.
University guidance emphasises that all projects that involve direct contact with human participants or where there may be any other ethical issues should be subject to ethical review. Your research must also conform to all legal requirements, which include compliance with relevant data protection legislation (GDPR) and undergoing appropriate screening (e.g. DBS) when working with vulnerable groups.
It is important that whilst you are undertaking research you follow the accepted research procedures and behave appropriately. This requires you to:
- obtain the appropriate ethical approval for your research before you begin.
- avoid unreasonable risk or harm to humans or animals used in research and to the environment.
- obtain appropriate permissions to undertake research from participants and organisations;
• handle privileged or confidential information on individuals collected during research in an approved manner including appropriate disposal of such material. - follow approved procedures when producing or dealing with hazardous materials including chemical, biological, and genetically modified materials.
If you are planning to use human participants in your dissertation project – either to assess/evaluate your deliverable, as respondents in your data collection, as subjects of experimentation, etc. you must consider the ethical implications of the research and take the appropriate actions to safeguard your subjects.
Prior to the collection of any data, you are required to complete the appropriate Research Ethics Proforma and to obtain any necessary ethical approvals for your research.
The relevant Ethics forms are:
UREC1 – No participants
UREC2 – Low-risk participants
UREC3 – High-risk participants
You must complete the appropriate UREC form in consultation with your supervisor and then submit the UREC form to Blackboard before the deadline specified. The final approval of projects will be registered on the Blackboard site as evidence of successful ethics review.
You MUST then undertake your research in strict accordance with the ethical approval received. If you wish to change any of the procedures described in your Student Ethics Checklist or add any others, you MUST discuss this with your supervisor and submit an amended Proforma. You CANNOT proceed until your amendment is approved. Failure to follow or comply with the correct procedures may result in an allegation of unethical practice under the Academic Misconduct Policy.
The University’s policies and procedures can be found at: Policies | Sheffield Hallam University (shu.ac.uk)
You will find that the relevant information for MSc Dissertation projects can be found under “Students – Research Ethics for undergraduate and Masters dissertations” section at: Approvals – Taught Courses | Sheffield Hallam University (shu.ac.uk)
VERY IMPORTANT:
If a student begins their dissertation project without research ethics scrutiny having occurred and approval being in place, she/he will AUTOMATICALLY BE DEEMED TO HAVE FAILED THE PROJECT
You are required to include evidence that the research ethics scrutiny has occurred in the appendices of your Dissertation report. Therefore, you MUST include your Ethics form completed and approved as Appendix B in your report.
3.2 GDPR compliance
Since 25 May 2018, the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) governs the way the University uses personal data. Personal data is information relating to an identifiable living individual. As part of this, you are obliged to inform participants about:
- How and why you are to use personal data for your research project.
- What the participant’s rights are under GDPR.
- How to contact the University if any participant has any questions or concerns about the use of the data you collect.
To comply with the above, you MUST:
- Inform participants about the legal basis under which you do research, inform them who to complain to if they feel that there have been any data breaches or that their treatment has been unsatisfactory.
- Gather their consent to participate.
3.2.1 Information sheet
You must appropriately inform your participants about the purpose of your research project and their participation. In order to decide whether to participate, subjects need to know what they are expected to do, how long it will take, what information will be gathered, whether there are any risks involved, what the expected benefits are, etc. You will find detailed advice to prepare your information sheet in the “Guidance on preparing a participant information sheet” document prepared by the University.
The above guidance also states that participants have a right to know the legal basis under which you do research; they also have the right to know who to complain to if they feel there have been any data breaches or that their treatment has been unsatisfactory. Hence your information sheet MUST include the following:
The University undertakes research as part of its function for the community under its legal status. Data protection allows us to use personal data for research with appropriate safeguards in place under the legal basis of public tasks that are in the public interest. A full statement of your rights can be found at: https://www.shu.ac.uk/about-this-website/privacy-policy/privacy-notices/privacy-notice-for-research
All University research is reviewed to ensure that participants are treated appropriately, and their rights respected. This study was approved by the BTE College Teaching Program Research Ethics Committee under the governance of the University Research Ethics Committee. Further information at: www.shu.ac.uk/research/excellence/ethics-and-integrity
Details of who to contact if you have any concerns or if adverse effects occur after the study are given below:
You should contact the Data Protection Officer if:
inappropriately), DPO@shu.ac.uk |
You should contact the Head of Research Ethics (Dr Mayur Ranchordas) if: ethicssupport@shu.ac.uk |
| Postal address: Sheffield Hallam University, Howard Street, Sheffield S1 1WBT. Telephone: 0114 225 5555 |
3.2.2 Consent form
When involving human participants in a research project, each potential participant must be adequately informed of the aims, methods, anticipated benefits and potential hazards of the research and any discomfort it may entail.
Consent should normally be in writing and records of consent should be maintained. The university has produced a Participant Consent Form, which you can use as starting point to produce your own. You will need to consider that any information given to potential participants should be comprehensible and there should be an opportunity for them to raise any issues of concern.
Potential participants must be informed that they are free to withdraw consent to participation at any time during the study and up to a specified date after the data has been collected unless data collection is anonymous.
All participants should be volunteers, and considerable care should be taken where consent is sought from those in a dependent position and it should be made clear that refusal to participate will not lead to any adverse consequences. Consent must be obtained from a legal guardian in the case of minors or for any others who do not have the legal competence to give informed consent, in the latter case research ethics review must be undertaken by the HRA IRAS System.
3.2 Publication Procedure
While it is relatively rare for MSc students’ research to be published, it can happen if your supervisor judges your work to be of a high enough standard to merit publication as a piece of work undertaken at SHU.
In this module, while you create your own research question or topic area, your supervisor makes a significant intellectual contribution to this work as the research progresses. Your supervisor
will make the decision
on whether your work merits publication based on the quality of the work you have produced. Your supervisor will co-author the paper for publication with you and your supervisor will both be listed as authors. You are required to sign the declaration below to confirm that you understand and will follow this procedure.
Declaration:
| I ………………………….. confirm that I understand will comply with the Publication Procedure outlined in the Module Handbook and the Blackboard Site. |
| Student: | Signature | Date |
| Supervisor: | Signature | Date |
The above information is included in Appendix B, please discuss this with your supervisor, fill the form before beginning your project, and include it in your final Dissertation submission.
Assessment of the Dissertation
4.1 Dissertation Submission
You are required to submit an electronic version of your final dissertation report. You will find your Submission Point under the Assessment folder on Blackboard, as well as a TurnItIn link.
Work submitted to the Submission Point will be classed as your official submission:
- By submitting, you will be certifying that the file uploaded is your own work, and that the work of others is duly acknowledged and correctly referenced.
- You are also asked to upload your work to Turnitin (see below), but this will not be classed as your official submission.
- A receipt confirming that your work has been received will be emailed to you. It is YOUR responsibility to ensure that your work is successfully submitted. Always check your email receipt and the submission point to confirm your work has uploaded successfully. If there is a problem with your submission you can make changes or resubmit your work up to the given deadline. The last attempt you submit will be the attempt that is marked.
- If you have a learning contract which states that you must submit work with a blue sticker on it, type the words from the blue sticker at the top of the front page of your work.
- You must ensure that your work is submitted using a file format(s) that can be accessed using university equipment.
- Further guidance, including what to do if you are unable to submit, can be found on Assessment4Students
As pointed out above, you are also asked to upload your work to Turnitin, but this will not be classed as your official submission.
- This is to ensure that you have correctly referenced and cited all information used in your Dissertation and thus avoid inadvertently plagiarising other people’s work.
- The Originality Report provided by Turnitin UK will be available for markers to examine.
You will not be penalised if minor amendments are made to the final version of the Dissertation report prior to uploading it to the Submission point.
- The Turnitin submission link will be set up to allow multiple submissions, thus allowing you to use the service in a formative manner, making the necessary changes to your Dissertation report to ensure correct referencing and presentation of material used.
4.1.1 Confidentiality
Your Dissertation becomes a public document once submitted. If material within the dissertation is commercially sensitive, you must include a statement on the Cover page stating that the dissertation is confidential in order that the document is not lodged in the library. Example statements are provided on the example Cover page given in Appendix A.
The current guidelines for confidential projects are:
- Any Dissertation can be registered as confidential, but evidence as to the reason for the confidentiality MUST be provided as an Appendix (e.g. written correspondence from the client organisation requesting confidentiality).
- Confidential project reports MUST be clearly marked as so, by including the appropriate statement on the Cover page. If a Dissertation is not marked as confidential it may be placed in the University Library for public access.
- Confidential Dissertations will only be available to those people directly involved in the assessment of the research project, and the Dissertation will not be placed in the University Library.
- Any data used for the project MUST be deleted from all University systems at the conclusion of the project unless explicit permission for other uses has been granted by the client. It is the responsibility of the student to ensure this is done.
- Any intellectual property issues must be formally recorded. The ownership of any intellectual property rests with the University and/or the client.
4.3 The Assessment Process
The dissertation is assessed to gauge to what extent the learning outcomes outlined earlier have been achieved. There is an assumption that the student will have undertaken a piece of research. This research work will have been defined in the research proposal, which itself will have been agreed with the supervisor.
It is important to note that it is the dissertation that is being assessed. Even where there have been severe problems with the research work, it should still be possible for the student to gain a distinction in the dissertation, by reflecting upon the nature of these problems and proposing ways to address them. Often the output of good dissertations can be a reformulation of the research problem itself.
These guidelines have been drawn up to ensure that dissertations are assessed in an objective, consistent and constructive manner. The assessment criteria are set at a level of abstraction high enough so that they can be used to assess any MSc dissertation across the Courses this applies to.
It is assumed that the Dissertation is presented according to the standards laid down in this document. Until the dissertation accords with such standards, it will not be assessed.
Your Dissertation will be examined by your supervisor and a second marker, and sometimes an external examiner. It may also be subject to further scrutiny by a third party to ensure consistency across the different courses and awards.
You will not hear the result of your Dissertation until after the next Award Board for your chosen award. You will then receive the mark that has been agreed by the Board for your Dissertation.
4.4 The Assessment Criteria
The dissertation is assessed against the following criteria that indicate the qualities expected of a master’s level dissertation within the College of BTE. Every Dissertation should normally meet all the criteria:
- Elucidation of the problem. You are expected to explain the problem to be addressed in your research project and justify why the project is needed. Your rationale should be supported by references to current research. The research question, aims and objectives should follow and be clearly stated, and the deliverable identified.
- Knowledge of the domain. This includes your use of the literature and its application to the project, and your understanding of key concepts. Related systems, products, artefacts, etc. should be identified and their relevance for the project discussed.
- Justification of approach. This includes your choice of approach and rationale for this choice. Describe and justify your research methodology and development/ implementation decisions (tools, techniques, models, software, architectures, development environments, equipment, etc.), and data collection and analysis choices. •Application of the selected approach. Show how the chosen approach was implemented; include evidence of the process followed.
- Data analysis, testing. Show how you arrived at the results/findings of your project; include evidence of the process followed. Demonstrate how the results were used in the development of the deliverable. Where appropriate, your deliverable should be tested; explain the choice of tests performed.
- . Discuss and justify your evaluation approach and the feedback gathered. Present the conclusions of the project conducted and relate this back to the original problem and its objectives.
Evaluation of deliverable. The deliverable of your project must be
evaluated by
potential beneficiaries/users
- Quality and usefulness of the deliverable. Considers the extent to which the deliverable is useful, of good quality, and addresses the original problem and objectives of the project.
- Quality of the report. This includes the presentation of an argument, backed up with evidence drawn from the research and with the use of references to the literature, following acceptable academic practice. The dissertation should be clearly structured in a way that supports the argument presented and leads to the conclusions that were researched, placed in an academic context.
Although dissertations may differ in form due to the subject area in question, they will still demonstrate the substance of the academic criteria in terms of academic quality.
For example, a dissertation discussing the performance characteristics of different networking protocols using a scientific method will be different in content and structure to a dissertation investigating the information needs of a psychiatric unit dealing with serious psychoses, employing an ethnographic framework. However, comparable levels of academic rigour will be required for both dissertations.
You should refer to the assessment criteria matrix in Appendix D for the fail/pass/distinction levels for each criterion.
4.5 Demonstrations and oral presentations
It is strongly recommended that you demonstrate your deliverable to your supervisor. The demonstration is not a formal assessment process, nor is it mandatory. It is a chance for you to show off the work conducted.
You should discuss this with your supervisor and arrange a suitable time and place for your demonstration.
Demonstrations should be arranged closer to your dissertation’s deadline. It is YOUR RESPONSIBILITY to arrange any such demonstrations.
Additionally, markers might require you to present your work -even if you haven’t arranged a demo. This presentation is not a formal assessment process, nor is it mandatory. It is an opportunity for your markers to look at your work in more detail, and to ask for clarification, if needed. It is strongly recommended that you attend the presentation if requested by your supervisor.
4.6 Failure to comply with Ethics procedures
As discussed in section 3 above:
If a student begins their dissertation project without research ethics scrutiny having occurred and approval being in place, she/he will AUTOMATICALLY BE DEEMED TO HAVE FAILED THE PROJECT
Please ensure that you have obtained approval from your supervisor (and research ethics committee, if applicable) before starting your project; evidence this in your Ethics checklist form which MUST be included as an Appendix in your Dissertation submission. If you fail to comply with this requirement,
you will automatically fail your project regardless of the
assessment produced by your markers
.
- Rules and regulations
You should refer to MyHallam for the rules and regulations at https://students.shu.ac.uk/regulations/
You should bear in mind particularly that, as happens with other work during the taught phase of the degree, you must submit the dissertation by the set date.
5.1 Procedure for Requesting an Extension
An extension should be requested when unexpected and unanticipated difficulties adversely impact your studies and your ability to submit your dissertation by the deadline date.
If you need a short extension to complete your dissertation, you need to complete a Request to Extend a Submission Deadline (RESD) via MyStudentRecord
AT LEAST 24 hours
before the submission deadline
. You will also have to upload the work you have done to date. Extensions will be granted (or not) by the Student Support Services Team (NOT the Dissertation Co-ordinators, Module Leader, or your Supervisor).
You will receive an email confirming the outcome of your request within 48 hours and MSR will also be updated. You can find detail information about applying for an extension at: KA-01853 · Customer Self-Service (shu.ac.uk).
Further information is available within the Extenuating Circumstances Policy.
Useful References on the dissertation process
- Cottrell, S. (2014). Dissertations and Project Reports. A step by step guide. Palgrave. McMillan.
- Gill, J., Johnson, P., & Clark, M. (2010). Research methods for managers (4th ed). Los Angeles, Cal.: SAGE.
- Phillips, E and Pugh, D. (2000). How to get a PhD, 2 ed. Milton Keynes: OUP.
- (Although originally aimed at PhD students this book provides quite useful guidance to anyone conducting a postgraduate dissertation, namely on the practical management and personal aspects of undertaking a substantial piece of research based work and on managing the relationship with the supervisor)
- Rudestam, K. E., & Newton, R. R. (2014). Surviving your dissertation: a comprehensive guide to content and process (Fourth edition). Thousand Oaks, California: SAGE Publications, Inc.
- Robson, C. (2011). Real world research: a resource for users of social research methods in applied settings (3rd ed). Hoboken, N.J.: Wiley.
- Saunders, M., Thornhill, A., & Lewis, P. (2016). Research methods for business students (Seventh edition). Harlow: Pearson Education.
- Yin, R. K. (2018). Case study research and applications: design and methods (Sixth edition). Los Angeles: SAGE.
Appendix A – Dissertation Cover Page
MSc Dissertation Report
| “Enter the Title of your Dissertation Project here” |
A dissertation submitted in partial fulfilment of the requirements of Sheffield Hallam University for the degree of Master of Science in [ENTER COURSE TITLE]
| Student Name |
| Student ID |
| Supervisor |
| Date of Submission |
INCLUDE EITHER STATEMENT 1 OR
STATEMENT 1:
This dissertation does NOT contain confidential material and thus can be made available to staff and students via the library.
STATEMENT 2:
This dissertation IS CONFIDENTIAL and circulation should be restricted to those involved in its assessment only.
Appendix B – Publication Procedure Form
PUBLICATION PROCEDURE FORM
In this module, while you create your own research question or topic area, your supervisor makes a significant intellectual contribution to this work as the research progresses. Your supervisor
will make the decision
on whether your work merits publication based on the quality of the work you have produced. Your supervisor will co-author the paper for publication with you and your supervisor will both be listed as authors. You are required to sign the declaration below to confirm that you understand and will follow this procedure.
Declaration:
I ………………………….. confirm that I understand will comply with the Publication Procedure outlined in the Module Handbook and the Blackboard Site. G5 | ||
| Student: | Signature | Date |
| Supervisor: | Signature | Date |
Appendix C – Pre-submission Checklist
PRE-SUBMISSION CHECKLIST
Before submitting the final version of your dissertation, please complete the checklist below.
Is the Cover Page as specified in the Dissertation guidelines?
Have you included a confidentiality statement on the Title Page, if applicable?
Have you included an Abstract?
Have you included your Research Project Plan as an Appendix?
Have you included the appropriate Research Ethics Proforma as an Appendix?
Have you included your Publication Procedure form as an Appendix?
Have you included a link to your primary data as an Appendix?
If applicable, have you included a link to your code as an Appendix?