Critical Analysis of ECtHR Jurisprudence and Domestic Applications
Toggle
M33224 Assignment: Critical Analysis of ECtHR Jurisprudence and Domestic Applications under the Human Rights Act 1998
| University | University Of Portsmouth (UOP) |
| Subject | M33224: Human Rights Law |
Assignment: Human Rights Law Case Analysis
Part A
In light of recent case law of the European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR), including the case of Verein KlimaSeniorinnen Schweiz and Others v. Switzerland [GC] 9 April 2024 (Application No. 53600/20), critically discuss whether the ECtHR is overdeveloping the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR) beyond its natural limits.
Part B
Question 1
Emma has recently broken up with Ryan, but he refused to accept it. Furious, he began sending her aggressive voice messages, telling her, “You’ll regret this.” A few days later, Emma found her car tyres slashed and a message spray-painted onto her garage door reading, “Last chance—talk to me, or else.” Concerned for her safety, she reported the threats to the police.
Ryan was brought in for questioning at a police station based in Portsmouth, but he refused to answer and only responded with “no comment.” As the interview continued, an officer grabbed Ryan’s arm and pulled him close to mutter, “If I were you, I’d be very careful from now on.” Ryan smirked at the time, but later admitted the comment unsettled him. The police released Ryan with a warning.
Later that week, a bystander witnessed an argument between Emma and Ryan outside her house. As the confrontation escalated, Ryan shoved Emma to the ground, causing her to hit her head on the pavement and fall unconscious. The bystander immediately called the police, but due to ambulance shortages, emergency services took nearly 40 minutes to arrive. By the time paramedics reached her, Emma had died.
Meanwhile, the police launched a search for Ryan, who had fled the scene. Officers eventually spotted him running towards an abandoned warehouse and ordered him to stop. He refused and attempted to climb a fence to escape. One officer fired a warning shot at Ryan, but he continued to climb the fence. After another verbal warning, the officer shot another two warning shots in quick succession, one of which accidentally hit Ryan in the shoulder. Ryan lost his grip of the fence and fell around 5 feet to the ground below, suffering a fractured wrist.
Despite bleeding from his shoulder and complaining of blurred vision, Ryan was taken into custody for questioning. One of the officers knew Emma and was particularly upset at what had happened. When other officers were out of the room, this officer twisted Ryan’s injured arm until he confessed to pushing Emma. Ryan was then taken to hospital and treated for his injuries where he made a full recovery. An internal police review was conducted into the case, but no significant wrongdoing was found, and the investigation was quickly closed.
Advise Ryan and Emma’s mother on whether they could bring a claim under the Human Rights Act 1998, and if so, whether there is a substantive breach of Article 2 or 3 ECHR.
Question 2
A large music festival is taking place in Hyde Park, London, attracting thousands of attendees. Given concerns about public safety and drug-related incidents, additional police officers are deployed to monitor the event. Facial recognition cameras have been installed at entrance gates and nearby transport hubs, scanning attendees against a database of individuals with drug-related or public order convictions from the past three years. This information is added to the watchlist and used to identify individuals who may be of interest to the police.
Ali, a local student, is returning home from a university trip when he unknowingly walks past one of the cameras near Marble Arch station. The system flags him as a person of interest, and police officers stop him as he exits the station. Confused, Ali asks why he is being questioned. The officers explain that they are trying to prevent troublemakers from entering the festival. Ali insists he has no interest in the festival and is just passing through. However, the officers say they would still “like to have a word” with him. Ali, feeling frustrated, tries to walk away but is stopped, and an officer grabs his arm.
They inform him that he cannot leave until they complete their inquiries. After a 15-minute questioning session and a pat-down search, it turns out that Ali was flagged due to a previous fine for drink driving. The officers apologise and release him. When Ali asks for his name to be removed from the watchlist, the officers explain that this is not possible.
Inside the festival, Tom manages to push his way to the front of the crowd during a performance by a well-known DJ. Excited by the music, he starts climbing onto the barrier, trying to crowd-surf, despite multiple security warnings against it. Festival security personnel tell him to get down, but Tom refuses, shouting, “This is a festival, let me enjoy it!”. As security moves toward him, he shoves an officer’s arm away, insisting that he isn’t doing anything wrong. The disturbance causes several other festival-goers to react, some cheering him on while others complain that he is disrupting the show. Concerned that the situation might escalate, a police officer steps in and decides to remove Tom from the crowd.
Instead of ejecting him from the festival, the officer escorts Tom to a room near the security checkpoint to calm down. Tom argues that he has done nothing wrong and demands to leave, but security informs him that they are acting in the interest of public safety. After 90 minutes, he is finally allowed to return, but by then, his favourite artist’s set is over.
Frustrated after being detained, Tom heads to a pub outside the festival grounds and drinks heavily. Later that evening, he stumbles into a group of festival-goers and starts arguing with them. A passer-by calls the police. When officers arrive, Tom, still angry from his earlier experience, begins swearing at them. As a result, he is arrested for a public disorder offence, handcuffed, and placed in the back of a police van. While being transported, Tom vomits all over himself due to excessive alcohol consumption.
The officers pull over to assist him and ask him to remove his soiled shirt, which they then discard in a nearby bin due to its condition. Tom is placed back in the van and taken to the police station, where he is held overnight. The next afternoon, he is released at 4 PM. Upon his release, the officers provide him with a replacement t-shirt from lost property. No further charges are pursued, but Tom is given a formal warning about his behaviour.
Advise Ali and Tom on whether they could bring a claim under the Human Rights Act 1998, and if so whether there is a substantive breach of Article 5 or 8 ECHR.
Question 3
Liam works as a researcher for a local authority in Birmingham. He has a strong belief in alternative health theories, including the idea that vaccines are harmful and unnecessary. While he often discusses his views casually with colleagues during lunch breaks, he also recently brought up these views in a company-led health and safety seminar, questioning the effectiveness of workplace vaccination policies. After receiving complaints from multiple employees who felt uncomfortable with his remarks, Liam is called into a formal disciplinary meeting.
His manager presents him with a document requiring him to refrain from discussing anti-vaccine views at work and to confirm that he supports the company’s health and safety policies. Liam refuses to sign the document, arguing that his beliefs should not impact his employment. As a result, he is dismissed for violating workplace conduct policies.
Frustrated, Liam takes to social media to air his grievances. He makes multiple posts, including one that states “This local authority is a joke” and another calling his manager a corrupt fraud who should be executed. Several employees report his posts, and the police become involved. He is subsequently charged under the Malicious Communications Act 1988 for sending offensive and threatening messages online.
Following the backlash from Liam’s case, the local authority introduces a new neutrality policy. This policy states that all employees must maintain a neutral stance on personal beliefs in the workplace, prohibiting the display of religious symbols or personal ideologies in the office. Arjan, a long-time employee, is informed that in line with the new policy he is no longer permitted to wear a turban, which he wears pursuant to his religious beliefs. Arjan refuses to remove his turban, arguing that the policy unfairly targets religious expression. Despite his objections, he is dismissed for failing to comply with the new policy.
Wanting to raise awareness about inclusivity, Arjan and Liam begin to protest outside the local authority offices. They distribute leaflets promoting acceptance and workplace diversity. Sarah, a senior employee at the local authority, sees one of these leaflets and takes offence at the idea of diversity initiatives being promoted outside the workplace. The next day, Sarah arrives at work wearing a t-shirt that says “Take Back Our Office” and begins distributing flyers depicting people of different religious backgrounds being escorted out of a corporate building. Employees report her behaviour, and she is later convicted under the Malicious Communications Act 1988 for promoting grossly offensive and discriminatory content.
Are you stressed about your M33224 Human Rights Law Coursework 2024/25 Assignment? There’s no need to worry! We are here to assist and provide zero-AI Student Assignment Help UK of high quality with original content written by our PhD expert writers. Also, we have free sample assignments so you can get an idea of the quality. Now stop worrying about late submissions and contact us for the best grades. Hand over your assignment worries to our experts today!
Order this Assignment Now: £89
Social Links
Contact Us
Secure Payment
![]()
Quicklinks
Services
- Assignment Reference
- Coursework Writing
- CV Writer Online
- Dissertation
- Essay Writing Tips
- Homework Help Services
- Online Exam
- Research Paper
- HND Assignment
- Thesis writing
- Cheap Assignment Help
Subject
- Nursing Essay Service
- Case Study Writing
- HR Assignment Help
- ATHE Assignment Help
- Make My Assignment
- Phd Writer Service
- Law Assignment Help
- CMI Assignment Help
- PGCE Assignment Help
- OTHM Assignment Help
t
- CIM Assignment Help
- CIPD Assignments
- Assignment Proofreading
- Dissertation Editing Services
- University Assignment Help
- Last Minute Assignment Help
- Psychology Essay
- Do My Assignment
- Buy Essay Online
- Write my Essay
Cities
- Assignment Help London
- Assignment Help Glasgow
- Assignment Help Coventry
- Assignment Help Plymouth
- Assignment Help Cardiff
- Assignment Help Leicester
- Assignment Help Bristol
- Assignment Help Luton
- Assignment Help Leeds
- Assignment Help Croydon
- View All Locations
- Assignment Help London
- Assignment Help Glasgow
- Assignment Help Coventry
- Assignment Help Plymouth
- Assignment Help Cardiff
- Assignment Help Leicester
- Assignment Help Bristol
- Assignment Help Luton
- Assignment Help Leeds
Disclaimer: Assignmentmentor.co.uk provides custom-written papers to assist students in research, writing, and proofreading. These assignments are for assistance purposes only.
Copyright © 2025 All rights reserved.
We value your privacy
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, serve personalised ads or content, and analyse our traffic. By clicking "Accept All", you consent to our use of cookies.
Customise Consent Preferences
We use cookies to help you navigate efficiently and perform certain functions. You will find detailed information about all cookies under each consent category below.
The cookies that are categorised as "Necessary" are stored on your browser as they are essential for enabling the basic functionalities of the site.
We also use third-party cookies that help us analyse how you use this website, store your preferences, and provide the content and advertisements that are relevant to you. These cookies will only be stored in your browser with your prior consent.
You can choose to enable or disable some or all of these cookies but disabling some of them may affect your browsing experience.
Always Active
Necessary cookies are required to enable the basic features of this site, such as providing secure log-in or adjusting your consent preferences. These cookies do not store any personally identifiable data.
No cookies to display.
Always Active
Functional cookies help perform certain functionalities like sharing the content of the website on social media platforms, collecting feedback, and other third-party features.
No cookies to display.
Always Active
Analytical cookies are used to understand how visitors interact with the website. These cookies help provide information on metrics such as the number of visitors, bounce rate, traffic source, etc.
No cookies to display.
Always Active
Performance cookies are used to understand and analyse the key performance indexes of the website which helps in delivering a better user experience for the visitors.
No cookies to display.
Always Active
Advertisement cookies are used to provide visitors with customised advertisements based on the pages you visited previously and to analyse the effectiveness of the ad campaigns.
No cookies to display.
WhatsApp us