Skip to content
+44 7386783749

Natural Resource Governance in Developing and Fragile Areas PES7045-B

FMLSS/PSID

Natural Resource Governance in Developing and Fragile Areas, PES7045-B

TYPE OF ASSESSMENT : ESSAY

COURSEWORK BRIEF

Assessment details Write one essay of 3,300 – 3,500 words. The assessment of this essay will constitute 85% of your overall assessment for the module.

Your essay question should be selected from the following list of essay questions. No other titles/questions will be accepted, unless expressly authorised in writing by the Module Leader.

Note you should not select an essay question that directly overlaps with your group project question. If in doubt, consult with the Module Leader.

Note also the guidance on essay focus and content provide below the list of essay questions: this is important, and will be taken into account in the assessment of your submitted essay.

These essay questions are provisional and still subject to change, pending review by the External Examiner. However they do provide a reliable basis for starting to select and prepare your essay.

In

addition, your assessed essay document should have an additional appendix containing a

300-word reflection detailing (with precision) how the topic was discussed in class (and any relevant tutorial or office hours discussions); how these discussions informed your thinking and decision-making when researching, structuring and developing the analysis in your essay

Please select one of the following essay questions

Please ensure that your essay directly addresses the full question as asked, drawing upon relevant themes and debates discussed in the module teaching sessions. You should develop and illustrate your answer with empirical experience relating to natural resource governance in developing or fragile areas, as well as reviewing and using relevant academic literature on the topic. Sub-titles, diagrams, tables, boxes, figures etc are welcome, and do not count towards the word length (and neither do the references or bibliography).

Your choice of question and case studies for your essay must not substantially overlap with the question or case study in your group project. If in doubt, consult with the Module Leader

  1. Assess the extent to which community-based approaches to natural resource management in developing countries are more likely to be effective and sustainable than state government-led approaches. Further develop your assessment using experience relating to one type of natural resource or geographical context of your choice.
  2. Critically assess the strengths and weaknesses of participatory management approaches to natural resource management, in which the state delegates management rights and responsibilities to local or user communities. Further develop your assessment in relation to ONE of the following types of natural resources: forests; wetlands; coastal fisheries; or access to potable freshwater.
  3. Assess the significance of natural resource tenure disputes for insecurity and political instability in fragile developing countries. Further develop your analysis by focussing on one or more countries or sub-regions of your choice.
  4. To what extent, and in what contexts, are the problems of natural resource governance and rights a major factor in the overall fragility of developing countries? Further develop your analysis by drawing on evidence from one of more case studies (of your choice).
  5. ‘Community management of natural resources in developing countries is as prone to injustice, unsustainability, and conflict risks as is management by state authorities’. Critically assess the extent to which, and contexts in which, this statement is valid.
  6. Examine and assess the critical factors that determine whether natural resource scarcity increases the likelihood of co-operation or violent conflict in fragile states. Discuss the implications of your findings for donor-supported programmes that aim to enhance resilience in such states.
  7. Examine the actually-existing systems of land tenure in a developing or fragile country of your choice; including their mechanisms available for addressing land tenure disputes. Building on this examination, discuss the issues and priorities for improving the land tenure systems in relation to ONE of the following: women and girls; subsistence farmers; managing farmer-herder needs and tensions; or respect for indigenous people’s rights.
  8. Examine the extent to which, and how, systems of natural resource governance are gendered in a developing country or region of your choice; focussing on ONE of the following categories of natural resource: freshwater; agricultural or pastoral land; forests; biodiversity; or fisheries. To what extent is such a gender analysis essential to enable design of effective policies or programmes to improve sustainable management of such natural resources?
  9. Examine the opportunities and challenges for avoiding or mitigating natural resource curse risks by developing countries which

    have recently discovered

    major mineral resource wealth. Further develop and illustrate your examination by drawing on one or more case studies.
  10. To what extent, and in what contexts, has the Extractive Industries Transparency Initiative (EITI) been useful or important in helping fragile states to improve the governance of extraction and international trade of mineral resource wealth?.
  11. Examine the systems for natural resource governance which operate in practice in a fragile country or locality of your choice, focussing on ONE of the following types of resources: land; forestry; freshwater; coastal fisheries; or wildlife and biodiversity conservation.
  12. Examine the factors contributing to unsustainable exploitation of fish and other marine resources in EITHER Exclusive Economic Zones OR High Seas. On the basis of this analysis, assess the relevance and prospects for success of one approach (of your choice) aiming to improve sustainable management of such sea resources.
  13. Critically examine and assess the extent to which climate change adaptation strategies and measures in a developing or fragile country (of your choice) require wider reforms for natural resource governance in order to be effective.
  14. transnational river basin of your choice. To what extent are they useful in preventing or managing conflict over access or use of freshwater resources in this basin?

    Examine and assess the co-operative management arrangements or agreements for

    one

  15. Critically examine proposals or processes of major land tenure reform in a developing country of your choice. To what extent have these integrated measures been designed to ensure that the rural poor benefit from the reforms?
  16. Examine and assess the extent to which, and how, addressing natural resource governance issues is a priority as part of UN post-conflict peace-building and reconstruction missions and programmes in conflict-affected countries. Illustrate and further develop your analysis using one or more case studies.
  17. Examine and assess the relevance and effectiveness of policies and measures designed to promote adaptation or resilience to climate change impacts on poor vulnerable communities in a developing or fragile country of your choice; focussing on ONE of the following types of impacts: flooding; drought; sea level rise; extreme weather events; degradation of ecosystems.
  18. of the following environmental issues areas: climate change; biodiversity protection; fisheries; industrial pollution.

    Examine the significance and roles of international environmental regimes for enabling improved sustainability or equitability of natural resource governance in fragile developing states in

    one

  19. Examine the challenges and opportunities for ensuring that natural resource concessions to major national or international companies are granted and managed in a conflict-sensitive way. Develop your analysis in relation to ONE of the following sectors in fragile states: commercial logging; large-scale commercial farming; extraction of oil or gas; extraction of metals and other valuable minerals; or fishing

These questions draw upon learning from across the whole PES7045-B module.

Importance Guidance on essay preparation

Take care to directly address the full essay question as asked. If there is more than one part of the essay question, take care to address all elements of the question. Although we welcome appropriate use of evidence from empirical examples and case studies, take care not to try to answer a generic question by focussing solely on a single country or case study.

This guidance is really important. Essays that provide lots of interesting and potentially relevant contextual discussion but which do not directly address the key issues raised by the question risk being failed. Essays that systematically and directly engage with the question in a way that demonstrates you have properly understood the question, and have critically engaged with the relevant debates and evidence, are likely to receive a relatively good mark even if there are some problems with quality of expression and such like.

It is expected that essays will include discussion of the directly relevant concepts and debates that have been raised in the module’s lectures, seminars and lecture notes. More marks will be given for those essays that engage appropriately with the debates raised in class, and marks will be deducted from those which do not take into account such debates where relevant. Make sure to apply these debates to any case study.

We recommend that you develop a clear analytical structure for your essay before you write a full draft, in order to help to ensure that you systematically address the question. We (the Module Tutors) are happy to comment on draft essay outlines on request.

Please note that plagiarism, essay purchasing and the use of Artificial Intelligence (AI) has become highly problematic in the last year or so. Last year, a number of students were submitted for Academic Misconduct and found to be in breach, thus being excluded or having to resubmit with a cap on the mark between 0 and 40%. The advice is simple: DO NOT COPY from other sources or AI.

Also be careful of software that promises to make your essay better. Such software may well make use of AI and using it may be construed as AI-related plagiarism. We do not expect note-perfect grammar. Marks are given for engagement with the topic and sources, clarity of the debate, and coherent structure, rather than grammatical precision.

Ensure that you include the required appendix ( of approx 300 words) detailing how the issues raised by the essay relate to the discussions and materials of the relvant teaching sessions for this module; and how these have informed the structure, analysis and findings of your essay.

Grading

All essays need to demonstrate substantial research and reflection, and also critical awareness and engagement with relevant issues and debates discussed in the teaching sessions for the module.

  • To achieve 40-49% students must present a basic argument/analysis, which uses an appropriate number of academic sources, and which is comprehensibly written and most sources correctly referenced.
  • To achieve 50-59% students must present a coherent and focussed argument/analysis, which uses a good number of academic sources, and which is comprehensibly written and meets standard scholarly standards.
  • To achieve 60-69% students must present a coherent, focussed and convincing argument/analysis which uses a wide range of academic sources, and which is well written and meets or exceeds standard scholarly standards.
  • To achieve 70+% students must present a coherent, highly focussed, strong and persuasive argument/analysis which uses an excellent range of academic sources, and which is well written, edited and refined, and exceeds standard scholarly standards.

Assessment criteria and expectations will be communicated to students in dedicated sessions for assessment guidance, written guidance, and office hours.

The referencing style used at Bradford University is Harvard. You can find guidance on referencing here: Referencing and Plagiarism – Help – University of Bradford

Please use Arial font, size 12. Text should be 1.2 or double-spaced.

Submission of the essay will be via Canvas. A submission link will be set up within the Assessment folder. Your essay should be submitted as a Word document.

Work that is over the stated word length will attract a penalty in proportion to the additional words (e.g. 5%). Note that the word count relates to the number of words in the main text of the essay. It does not include: title and contents page; boxes, tables or figures; or footnotes and bibliography.

All submissions are checked by Turnitin plagiarism and AI detection software. A separate link in Canvas allows you to review your essay prior to submission. Please note that there is no permitted Turnitin score percentage. You should focus instead on ensuring your essay meets the university guidelines for referencing and academic integrity: What is plagiarism? – Find out about – University of Bradford

If you have any questions about this assignment, please speak with your module leader in good time before the deadline.

Please ensure you allow enough time for completing your work. Avoid submitting it very close to the deadline in case of technical issues (e.g. broken Wi-Fi). It is your responsibility to ensure you submit the correct file and on time.

Order this Assignment Now: £90